# Teeth whitening with a novel phthalimido peroxy caproic acid (PAP)

> This short communication describes a new professional teeth whitening technique using phthalimido peroxy caproic acid (PAP), which whitens teeth without releasing hydrogen peroxide or forming reactive oxygen species.

_Dr. med. dent. Stefan Stübinger · 2024-06-10_

## Why look for a gentler way to whiten teeth?

Teeth whitening has a long tradition as a minimally invasive alternative to veneers or crowns, which can be destructive and harmful, when the aim is to mask discolouration. Growing media and public interest in the smile has made dental aesthetics and oro-facial appearance as important in daily life as dental health itself.1 Oral health-related quality of life, which covers oral function, oro-facial pain, oro-facial appearance and psychosocial impact, is increasingly a key measure of how patients experience their oral health.2 

Yellow or stained teeth can have many causes, whether intrinsic, extrinsic or a combination of both.3 Extrinsic stains form when external chromogens settle on the tooth surface or in the pellicle. Intrinsic stains form when chromogens are deposited inside the tooth. The main causes are individual habits, diseases, injuries and various physiological processes.4 Over time, new methods and materials have been chosen to achieve a lasting whitening effect. Today there are two types of dentist-supervised techniques: at-home or in-office bleaching.5 

Home bleaching has a clear advantage: you save the trip to the dentist, and with it time and cost. However, the whitening effect is less pronounced and less lasting, because the concentration of bleaching agents and active ingredients is too low to change tooth colour noticeably. Soft tissue irritation and badly fitting trays are also common drawbacks.6 

For this reason, in-office bleaching (also called power bleaching) is a reliable alternative.7 Its stronger effect, however, relies on a more aggressive, invasive technique or on higher concentrations of ingredients, mostly hydrogen peroxide, which call for appropriate protective measures. Contact between hydrogen peroxide and the gums can cause severe damage to the epithelium. 

## Does teeth whitening damage enamel?

Acidic bleaching agents based on H2O2 are always associated with reactive oxygen species (ROS) such as hydroxyl (OH•) and perhydroxyl (HO2•) radicals. These free radicals diffuse through enamel and dentine and break the double bonds of pigmented molecules, so the tooth is perceived as whiter.8 The downside is that hydroxyl radicals (OH•) have certain harmful local effects, such as enamel erosion, changes in the microhardness of teeth, gum irritation, sensitive teeth after whitening and a burning sensation.9 To avoid these negative effects, an alternative approach is needed. 

## How does peroxide-free teeth whitening with PAP work?

It has recently been described that a composite gel based on peroxy caproic acid (PAP) can serve as an effective vehicle for teeth whitening. PAP proved to be nearly harmless to tooth enamel, with a safe and reliable whitening effect.10 When PAP is used clinically for teeth whitening, oxidation reactions take place, just as with classic methods. The chromogens, which consist of conjugated double bonds, are decolourised by chemical and physical processes. The difference is that the reaction takes place without the formation of free radicals. This is the major and decisive difference, because free radicals are the main cause of tooth sensitivity and gum irritation in conventional teeth whitening.11 

Against this background, the aim of this short communication is to introduce a novel two-component bleaching method based on a phthalimido peroxy caproic acid formulation. It also presents preliminary data on its efficacy and possible side effects.

## Materials and methods

The novel bleaching technology (ALPINE WHITE, Cobea AG, Dänikon, Switzerland) is a stable liquid preparation based on phthalimido peroxy caproic acid crystals in an aqueous suspension. It works without releasing hydrogen peroxide. The formulation is a two-component system. The main ingredients of the in-office whitening gel and the separate in-office activator are listed in Table 1. 

The product is sensitive to alkalis and solvents and should not be mixed with other chemicals without strong dilution in water or a specific compatibility assessment. It can be stored for two years after production if kept in its original container at room temperature. The material is intended for single use. Overall, the study consists of a retrospective clinical part and a preclinical investigation on human teeth. The in-vitro data are intended to support the clinical results. Case data from n=100 patients were evaluated retrospectively over a period of 3 months by one examiner (Table 2, Figures 1 and 2). Teeth with previous root canal treatment or fillings were not included in the analysis. The case analysis followed the procedure below.

Before whitening, the oral and perioral region was examined clinically for any signs of adverse changes to the teeth or adjacent soft tissue. All participants also received a professional clean and oral hygiene instruction. Certified dental hygienists carried out the bleaching procedures wearing protective goggles and gloves. Over a period of 90 minutes, n=4 application cycles of 15 minutes each were performed.

First, n=3 drops of activator were added to each portion of gel. The ingredients were mixed homogeneously with a spatula for 60 seconds. After a lip retractor was placed (Cheek Retractor Black, Guangzhou GT Health Industry Co. Ltd., Liantang Town, China), the ALPINE WHITE gel (ALPINE WHITE, Cobea AG, Dänikon, Switzerland) was applied manually to each tooth with a single-use brush. After 15 minutes, the bleaching gel was removed, the teeth were cleaned with gauze and rinsed with an air-water spray. Four bleaching sessions were carried out with each person, and the lip retractor was then removed. All participants were instructed to brush their teeth regularly with fluoride toothpaste afterwards. Efficacy (tooth shade) and safety (possible side effects) such as tooth sensitivity and gum irritation were documented at baseline and immediately after treatment. Tooth shade was determined with the VITA classic shade guide (Vita Zahnfabrik, Bad Säckingen, Germany), measuring the middle third of the facial surface of the upper and lower front teeth.

In addition to the retrospective clinical analysis, an in-vitro study was carried out in the laboratory on separate human teeth to evaluate the effects on the tooth surface. Healthy teeth without restorations or root canal treatments were used. All patients gave their informed consent for their teeth to be used in the tests. The teeth were cut vertically into 3–4 pieces, so that each piece had as large an area of tooth surface as possible. These pieces were placed on a PMMA block (Sigma Aldrich Chemie GmbH, Buchs, Switzerland) in a glass container. Liquid MMA (Sigma Aldrich Chemie GmbH, Buchs, Switzerland) was then added so that only the surface of the tooth sample remained free of PMMA. Once the MMA had polymerised, the tooth samples could be examined. As poorly conductive samples, the enamel surfaces were sputter-coated with an 8 nm conductive layer of gold-palladium (Au/Pd) (Leica Microsystems, Leica EM ACE600 Sputter-Coater, Heerbrugg, Switzerland) and imaged with a scanning electron microscope (SEM) (Thermo Scientific™ Axia™ ChemiSEM™, Reinach, Switzerland) at an acceleration voltage of 20 kV.

## **Results: whitening effect and enamel safety**

SEM analysis of the ALPINE WHITE group showed an unchanged surface morphology with no signs of damage to the enamel (Figure 3). After the tooth surfaces had been treated with ALPINE WHITE Whitening 4 times for 15 minutes, both the smooth areas (A, B) and the rough areas (C/D) of the bleached samples showed that the enamel was not damaged compared with the control samples treated with deionised water (E, F, G, H). No destruction or roughening of the surface could be detected in the PAP samples. The micropores remained intact. Overall, no general smoothing or washing out of the tooth surface could be seen in the PAP group. The effect of PAP was comparable to that of the water control group in both the rough and the smooth areas. The SEM results were supported by preliminary case reports.

Baseline demographic and clinical characteristics are shown in Table 2 and Figures 1 and 2. For the analysis, only shades A2 and A3 on the VITA scale were selected as starting shades. A clear improvement towards a lighter shade was observed for both A2 and A3 (Figures 4 and 5). In addition, only a small percentage of these preliminary cases showed a change to a different colour quality (colour range B). In the present preliminary cases, neither the clinicians nor the patients reported side effects or other problems.

## **Discussion**

As bleaching is one of the most frequently used aesthetic procedures in dentistry, demand for innovative and safe products is rising. In particular, avoiding hydrogen peroxide (HP) and its free radicals is increasingly sought after, because of concerns about its ability to penetrate enamel and dentine and so reach the pulp tissue. The resulting inflammatory reaction leads over time to bleaching-induced tooth sensitivity. Although this is only temporary, it is a barrier for many patients, who then give up on whitening.

The introduction of a new PAP-based method offers a promising solution for significant teeth whitening with negligible side effects, as the SEM analysis and initial case data show. Compared with conventional methods, this new bleaching technology is much gentler and shows no toxic effects on human tissue. It also leads to fewer problems and less hypersensitivity after bleaching. In the present test, however, no attempt was made to analyse dental or restorative materials with the new method.12 Our own unpublished data, though, revealed no negative effect on dental restorations.

For a deeper statistical evaluation, a larger number of cases is planned as part of an exploratory study. Here, the aim was only to introduce the SEM method, including the first positive results, and to use it as a starting point for further statistical evaluation. Another limitation of the current application is the number of treatment cycles. The current procedure needs 4 application cycles within 90 minutes to achieve the desired effect, which means a visit to a professional is still necessary. Nevertheless, further development is already aimed at a faster method for use at home. Future clinical studies must also prove the long-term effect of the new method.

## **Conclusion**

This short communication presents the successful use of a new two-component bleaching method based on a phthalimido peroxy caproic acid formulation, without the release of hydrogen peroxide. In contrast to conventional hydrogen peroxide whitening gels,10 phthalimido peroxy caproic acid (PAP) significantly reduced damage to teeth, with minimal impairment of surface morphology and hardness. Sensitivity after in-office bleaching with PAP is also reduced. Importantly, PAP shows a notable whitening effect without irritating the oral mucosa or dentine. In summary, this short communication underlines the promising and innovative nature of PAP-based teeth whitening technology, a significant advance in dental aesthetics and patient care.

The full peer-reviewed article was published on Dovepress on 10 June 2024. Professional in-office bleaching is carried out by your dentist or dental hygienist.

## Gentle teeth whitening at home

If you would like to support your results between dental visits, at-home teeth whitening is an easy option. Take a look at our [whitening strips](https://www.alpinewhite.com/en-EU/shop/whitening-strips) or the [Whitening Kit](https://www.alpinewhite.com/en-EU/shop/whitening-kit). If you have pain, bleeding gums or persistent sensitivity, see your dentist first.

## **Sources**

1. Alkahtani R, Stone S, German M, et al. A review on dental whitening. *J Dent*. 2020;100:103423. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2020.103423
2. Larsson P, Bondemark L, Häggman-Henrikson B. The impact of oro-facial appearance on oral health-related quality of life: a systematic review. *J Oral Rehabil*. 2021;48(3):271–281. doi:10.1111/joor.12965
3. Kahler B. Present status and future directions - Managing discoloured teeth. *Int Endod J*. 2022;55(Suppl 4):922–950. doi:10.1111/iej.13711
4. Gasmi Benahmed A, Gasmi A, Menzel A, et al. A review on natural teeth whitening. *J Oral Biosci*. 2022;64(1):49–58. doi:10.1016/j.job.2021.12.002
5. de Geus JL, Wambier LM, Kossatz S, et al. At-home vs In-office bleaching: a systematic review and meta-analysis. *Oper Dent*. 2016;41(4):341–356. doi:10.2341/15-287-LIT
6. Sulieman MA. An overview of tooth-bleaching techniques: chemistry, safety and efficacy. *Periodontol*. 2008;48(1):148–169. doi:10.1111/j.1600-0757.2008.00258.x
7. Dourado Pinto AV, Carlos NR, Amaral FLBD, et al. At-home, in-office and combined dental bleaching techniques using hydrogen peroxide: randomized clinical trial evaluation of effectiveness, clinical parameters and enamel mineral content. *Am J Dent*. 2019;32(3):124–132.
8. Singhal R, Namdev R, Singhal P, et al. Newer technique of extra-coronal bleaching with sodium perborate on non-pitted fluorosis stains in permanent anterior teeth. *J Clin Pediatr Dent*. 2022;46:112–118.
9. Bizhang M, Domin J, Danesh G, Zimmer S. Effectiveness of a new non-hydrogen peroxide bleaching agent after single use - A double-blind placebo-controlled short-term study. *J Appl Oral Sci*. 2017;25(5):575–584. doi:10.1590/1678-7757-2016-0463
10. Qin J, Zeng L, Min W, et al. A bio-safety tooth-whitening composite gels with novel phthalimide peroxy caproic acid. *Compos Commun*. 2019;13:107–111. doi:10.1016/j.coco.2019.04.002
11. Pascolutti M, de Oliveira D. A radical-free approach to teeth whitening. *Dent J*. 2021;9(12):148.
12. Ozverel CS, Kurtulmus-Yilmaz S. Effect of the application of a hydrogen peroxide home bleaching agent on the cytotoxicity of different CAD-CAM restorative materials. *Dent Med Probl*. 2023;60(2):311–320. doi:10.17219/dmp/142761

---
Canonical: https://www.alpinewhite.com/en-EU/article/tooth-whitening-with-a-novel-phthalimido-peroxy-acid
